{
  "schema": "cw-service-mapping-1",
  "id": "fedciv-retained-publication",
  "classification": "synthetic-only",
  "contextHash": "sha256:ad0ce700c3175f8b45e772d5cd2a80019eb33fc33ed2030ee3b33bcfcb0754ce",
  "sourcePackHash": "sha256:f3d2e216940cb264e5dba9a5357aa936cd247118c30ea820e5d3fe1eaa26f8c6",
  "sourceManifestHash": "sha256:40e193c83ada191ddd10953586fb9f3a6d0f1063928a9d649cae5f0e14a71bf4",
  "family": {
    "id": "family-fedciv-publication",
    "name": "Federal Environmental Data Office — fictional teaching case",
    "scope": "An entirely invented federal civilian office is considering agency-operated cloud foundations for a data-publication service that still depends on a retained on-site data service. No actual agency, client statement, provider entitlement or agreed schedule is represented."
  },
  "services": [
    {
      "id": "publication",
      "name": "Publication service operating handoffs",
      "scope": "Proposed discussion across an agency-operated foundation option and retained data service.",
      "boundaryLimitation": "Conceptual service scope; no verified technical or authorization boundary."
    },
    {
      "id": "capacity",
      "name": "Operations capacity planning",
      "scope": "Proposed examination of skills, support coverage and potential shared-service alternatives.",
      "boundaryLimitation": "No program entitlement, staffing acceptance or supplier commitment is established."
    }
  ],
  "decisions": [
    {
      "positionId": "AR-010",
      "disposition": "clarify",
      "serviceId": "publication",
      "rationale": "Collection coverage, service identifiers, retention, transport and transfer costs are unverified.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: central collection cannot yet be assumed. Compare federated summaries and central forwarding against coverage, permitted transfers and cost; retain both accounts until a trace resolves the disagreement.",
      "proposedOwner": "Enterprise monitoring lead — proposed",
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-012",
      "disposition": "include",
      "serviceId": "publication",
      "rationale": "The emergency-change path, rollback decision and incident-to-problem handoff have not been agreed.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: a linked change record and observable rollback can make the two operating cadences discussable. The rehearsal is proposed; no change authority, deployment success or recovery capability has been established.",
      "proposedOwner": "Service change lead — proposed",
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-014",
      "disposition": "include",
      "serviceId": "publication",
      "rationale": "Support hours, absence cover and the retained-service recovery handoff are unknown.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: cloud-side health would not prove the publication service has recovered while its retained data dependency is unavailable. A joint verification step and named backup coverage need discussion before a service commitment.",
      "proposedOwner": "Publication service and retained-data leads — proposed",
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-015",
      "disposition": "clarify",
      "serviceId": "publication",
      "rationale": "Service identity mapping, deduplication and the source of record are unresolved.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: do not select an AIOps correlation layer simply because alerts can create tickets. First reconcile service identity and timestamps, then evaluate a read-only association against a rules baseline; association is not root cause.",
      "proposedOwner": null,
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-032",
      "disposition": "exclude",
      "serviceId": null,
      "rationale": "Shared-cost ownership and bill-to-usage reconciliation are missing.",
      "interpretation": "Teaching scope choice: a full showback model is outside this narrow handoff rehearsal. Collection-cost uncertainty still constrains the architecture decision and is not resolved by excluding the workstream.",
      "proposedOwner": null,
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-048",
      "disposition": "clarify",
      "serviceId": "publication",
      "rationale": "Service outcome, measurement point and accepted objective remain undefined.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: retain the console check as a limited signal. Ask what the user can successfully do, which dependency must also work and who accepts the result; do not infer an SLO or restoration from a green console.",
      "proposedOwner": "Publication service lead — proposed",
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    },
    {
      "positionId": "AR-049",
      "disposition": "include",
      "serviceId": "capacity",
      "rationale": "Cloud platform coverage, onboarding effort and specialist availability are unknown.",
      "interpretation": "Consultant interpretation: investigate specialist support for bounded platform tasks while retaining internal service ownership. Neither outsourcing nor joining a program guarantees capacity, faster authorization or lower cost.",
      "proposedOwner": "Operations workforce lead — proposed",
      "reviewer": "Fictional teaching reviewer",
      "reviewedAt": "2026-10-06T00:00:00.000Z",
      "scopeHash": "sha256:65a79054d49304f85dccd314fcd4dde48f3b0a3f52aec5d4f6c5852948d8dc58"
    }
  ]
}